Skip to main content
Home

Main navigation

  • Free Appraisals
    • Get a Free Appraisal
    • View Appraisals
    • Local Appraisers
  • Classifieds
  • Blog
  • Shows
    • Antique Shows, Flea Markets, & Swap Meets Map
    • Upcoming Shows
User Menu
  • Login
  • Help
  • Register

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. Blog

American Pickers TV Show

I've watched American Pickers several times on TV. While I enjoy most shows related to antiques and collecting, such as Antiques Roadshow or Pawn Stars, I just can’t seem to get into this one. While the duo occasionally finds interesting items that are enjoyable to learn about, what bothers me is the impression that they’re often taking advantage of an older, unsuspecting seller who doesn’t seem to know the true value of their items.

The show highlights what I dislike most about collecting—the dynamics you sometimes encounter at swap meets, though usually in a less extreme form. I understand that they run a legitimate business and need to turn a profit to keep things going, but the way they negotiate feels overly opportunistic and, frankly, a bit slimy. Of course, this is just my personal impression, and others might see it differently.

The tall, skinny host, in particular, strikes me as someone who might even haggle with his own grandmother to get a better deal. This approach really puts me off the show. I’m curious to know what others think about American Pickers and its hosts. Do you enjoy their style, or do you share some of my concerns?

Angie.B.

12 years 9 months ago

In reply to Re: American Pickers TV Show by Joseph

Re: American Pickers TV Show

Don't forget that there are commercials in these half hour episodes. The money has to go somewhere. I myself like the Pawn Masters. They are a group of professional antique dealers and it's fun to watch them barter over a certain item. They're not worth a fortune but it keeps these people in business and it's interesting to see what people have in their homes.

Brenda K

14 years 4 months ago

Re: American Pickers TV Show

I have a ton of  stuff grandma left me , the reason I have not gotten rid of it, is because of people like this, who seem to be just on the take, hate the show, watched it a couple of times to make sure it was not just the one show, and no pickers allowed at my home Thanks to them, much rather watch the pawn show in vegas at least they are honest about what it is worth and you can decide to take it or leave it......and you learn something, love the show
Profile picture for user Joseph

Joseph

14 years 4 months ago

In reply to Re: American Pickers TV Show by Brenda K

Re: American Pickers TV Show

My sentiments exactly...

antiquesnoldthings

14 years 4 months ago

Re: American Pickers TV Show

I guess we all have things which annoy us. The "Pawn Stars" happen to be what annoys me. In most episodes, I find them condescending, if not downright rude. It is however, fun to see the old, odd and interesting pieces that come through their doors. Here's the kicker for me. There was an episode when a lady came in with a boxed, Faberge spider brooch, knowing nothing about it and wanting what she probably assumed was alot for it ($2,000.) Rick explained to her what she had and if I remember correctly, offered her $15,000. I would bet money that if the cameras weren't around and he didn't have a  TV / public eye reputation to worry about, that never would have happened. Chances are, she would have walked out with half or less her asking price, in keeping with their usual M.O.. As for the "Pickers," their home base is a couple of miles from where I'm located. I've met them personally, been to their shop and run into Frank occasionally at local estate sales. Aside of being goofy at times, they're pretty likable, down to earth guys. When you get right to it, the name of the game is buy low, sell high. Often times people don't have the resources, nor the desire to mess around trying to sell their things. Alot of folks don't even realize that they have valuables and are happy as clams when someone offers money for something they considered junk. If somebody comes along that is willing to pay what they are asking, or somewhere in that ballpark, they are pleased, even if undervalued.  The key is, do some research, know what  you have, consider the market and then decide for how much, where or to whom you want to sell. Remember, it's only worth what someone is willing to pay, despite it's book value. Sometimes there is a bit of taking of advantage of ignorance going on, but noone passes up a great deal, whether scrupulous or not...          

Profile picture for user wendyraeandersen

wendyraeandersen

14 years 4 months ago

In reply to Re: American Pickers TV Show by antiquesnoldthings

Re: American Pickers TV Show

I really enjoy both shows, and do not begrudge anyone trying to make a living. I really believe in Karma, and if they were truly greedy, it would come back three fold on them. I really see honest guys in a business that is less than that at many times. just thinkling about Mike and Frank selling the Carnival poster for  $10,000.00, and circling back to give the guy $5000.00, because it was woth more that they had thought.

michelle_o

14 years 3 months ago

In reply to Re: American Pickers TV Show by wendyraeandersen

Re: American Pickers TV Show

  I agree with wendy and like her posting ,however I also have seen both shows and can recall the spider brooch episode .Someone watching with us said the same thing about the cameras being gone and the price would have been way less.Maybe,maybe not but the people can get a second opinion.They do not have to say yes and sell right then.I do not care for pawn shops much but as others, I do enjoy the things people bring in.I like pickers and agree people have to make a living.There have been shows where they paid decent money for things and they were worth 0 dollars or cents so you know, be smart and do not take the first offer someone gives you.When in doubt have it checked out!!My Grandma has just passed in January she was 83 and is the reason I love antigue and vintage stuff.I would not get rid of anything that I thought I could pass on to mine,my brother or my sisters kids.What we do get rid of I will research myself or find sites like this one to help me.I refuse to sell her thing in a yard sale.She was veryy charitable and alot has and will be donated but the rest doesn't have to worth alot but it was her's and I want someone to have it who will appreciate it for what it is.

richie rich

14 years 4 months ago

Re: American Pickers TV Show

I too know that this show is not for real. How do they drive around in a Mercedes (that's what my husband says it is) burn all that gas, and where do they sleep? Sometimes a days work only brings a few hundred dollars profit! Now that's not doing good business! Let's see something real for a change and not all this scripted stuff that is refilmed to get the most affect. Let it happen naturally, your audience can tell when it is not for real!!

Tom J

14 years 2 months ago

In reply to Re: American Pickers TV Show by richie rich

Re: American Pickers TV Show

 

 Those picker dudes picked a neighbors garage some time ago

He didn't fare too well,..(Cheaped him big time)

. The truck is a dodge sprinter with a mercedes motor. I know someone else who has one. They get over 35 miles per gallon on the highway. That's why they can afford it. It is a fat price tag on it, but I think it pays them back in fuel costs.

Profile picture for user thdrbat

thdrbat

12 years 10 months ago

In reply to Re: American Pickers TV Show by Tom J

Mercedes/Dodge

http://www.google.com/imgres?q=dodge+sprinter&hl=en&sa=X&biw=1280&bih=945&tbm=isch&prmd=imvns&tbnid=bWVEv0ogcngQgM:&imgrefurl=http://www.allpar.com/trucks/sprinter.html&docid=P-qjc9rQ_fW6vM&imgurl=http://www.allpar.com/images/dodge/trucks/sprinter.jpg&w=616&h=406&ei=_ogFUN7eH-Lr0gGR3bnUCA&zoom=1Tom.....

This is a Dodge Sprinter....notice the difference? Altho Benz owned Chrysler at the time, this is still a Dodge. The vehicle on the show is a Mercedes.

 

Voyrrr

14 years 3 months ago

Re: American Pickers TV Show

Oh come on. The world economy is based on purchasing something at one price and selling it at a profit. You cant be offended by the Pickers and then go to the grocery store. Everything you purchase started off being sold for very little money. The average can of corn that sells for one dollar started out with the farmer for about 12 cents. It is the same with every business.
 
I have watched American Pickers since the beginning, and for the record, the items shown being purchased are a small percentage of what they actually buy. They have been in business for some time and have clients all around the country. My  only qualm is that more people are going to go out picking, and it is going to get harder for those who are trying to make a living at it; a living that is not as easy as it looks.
 
They dont try to rip people off. They make offers on what they see. Sometimes people sell and sometimes they dont. A person makes a choice to sell a particular item or not. They decide on what they will accept. Obviously, someone looking to buy things who come to your door with a list, driving a van with a big logo... is going to resell what they buy.
 
Now, as for Pawn Stars or Storage Wars.... when was the last time you went to a pawn shop with something as valuable as what they have on that show. Does the pawn shop ever call an expert? They are in Vegas, and my guess is that those folks dig up the last valuable thing they can find and run to the pawn shop so they can get back to the casino as fast as they can. And you can bet when the cameras are off, the "Pawn Stars" go back to buying items for pennies on the dollar. Pawn shop = bottom feeder.
 
Lastly, Storage Wars. Ick. Have you ever seen a slimier bunch of people on one program? I am sure there is an occasional good find in a unit, especially in Hollywood CA, but the average town will have average crap. I stopped watching that show because I couldnt stand to see such morally bankrupt people get so much pleasure out of being hateful to one another. ACK!

Pagination

  • First page
  • Previous page
  • Page 1
  • Page 2
  • Page 3
  • Page 4
  • Page 5
  • Next page
  • Last page
  • Log in or register to post comments

Today’s Featured Blog

How to Start a Collection: Tips for Beginners

More Blog articles…

Recent Appraisals

  • Louie Vuitton monogram never used purse
  • Johaan Haviland China
  • Rolex Watch
  • Vintage Black Karakul/Astrakhan Fur/Persian Lamb Muff
  • American Chippendale Slant Front Top Desk
  • Sunset Landscape Oil Paintings
  • Vintage HIFI Stereo System
  • Vintage Lamp
  • S.f & co england peraline
  • Old dollshouse with furniture
See more appraisals…

Recent Appraisal Comments

  • Louis Vuitton Monogram Popincourt Long Handbag (M40008)
  • Johann Haviland Bavaria Germany China Set (80 Pieces)
  • This set shows no chips or…
  • Watch Labeled Rolex Oyster Perpetual
  • Vintage Karakul/Astrakhan Fur Muff with Satin Backing
  • American Chippendale Slant-Front Desk (c. 1770–1790)
  • Sunset Landscape Oil Paintings (c. 1950s–1970s)
  • Vintage Onkyo Hi-Fi Stereo System (1970s)
  • Vintage Converted Oil Lamp (Electrified)
  • Antique "Pearline" Decorative Dish

Recent Blog Articles

  • How to Start a Collection: Tips for Beginners
  • Beyond the Price Tag: The Hidden Factors That Influence Antique and Collectible Value
  • Beyond the Price Tag: Unlocking the Hidden Stories in Your Family Heirlooms
  • Antiques as an Investment: Beyond the Hype, What's Actually Worth It?
  • Is it Real or Just Really Old? Your Guide to Spotting Fake Antiques (and How to Protect Yourself)
  • Beyond the Dust: Unearthing the Stories Behind Your Antiques (and Why Knowing Matters)
  • Unlocking Time's Treasures: Your Essential Vintage Watch Value Guide

More Blog articles…

© 1995- InstAppraisal™, Inc. All Rights Reserved Worldwide
Privacy Policy & Terms and Conditions of Use